Jake's right I glossed over that you'd given your notice. Having been both tenant & a LL, I just think they are jerking you around. However since your lease included the $125.00 fee there's not much you can do. You have to figure what your time and energy is worth to contest the 60 days. I'd be prepared however, if they want to ding you for damages. Personally, I'd chalk the 60 days up to the fact they didn't know enough to appreciate a good tenant. Good luck.