Re: Descrimintion in owner occupied 3 unit building NY

Re: Descrimintion in owner occupied 3 unit building NY by MrDan (Georgia) on June 21, 2012 @17:04

Posted on June 8, 2010 by Scott M. Badami
The "Mrs. Murphy" Exemption to the Fair Housing Act
The owners and management companies of the apartment communities I represent are almost always covered by the Fair Housing Act (FHA). In practice, the FHA and its implementing regulations are part of the guidebook concerning how we do business. The FHA does, however, contain a few exceptions -- one of the exemptions is referred to as the "Mrs. Murphy" exception.

"Mrs. Murphy's" Exemption provides that if a dwelling has four or fewer rental units and the owner lives in one of those units, that home is exempt from the FHA. "Mrs. Murphy" is the hypothetical elderly widow who has converted a portion of her home into a rental apartment to supplement her limited income.

To be sure, the exemption does not apply to rental advertising. That means Mrs. Murphy cannot run a discriminatory advertisement indicating, for example, that a certain religious group is not welcome to rent her apartment or room. Also, this exemption does not apply when a real estate agent is representing the property owner as the law presumes agents are professionally trained and aware that housing discrimination is against the law.

Also, HUD takes the position that the Civil Rights Act of 1866 (yes, 1866) makes it illegal to discriminate based on race -- and as such, there is not exemption from the law when dealing with race.

Should the "Mrs. Murphy's" of the world discriminate? Of course not. But, the FHA does not apply in this limited circumstance and it can be a defense to a housing discrimination action.

You should be aware that many States, Counties, Cities and Towns have their own Fair Housing laws also.

[ Reply ] [ Return to forum ]

Re: Descrimintion in owner occupied 3 unit building NY by Stephen (WA) on June 23, 2012 @23:14	[ Reply ]

Good explanation of "Mrs. Murphy" exemption. As mentioned, the exemption does not apply to advertisements therefore, Mrs. Murphy could not advertise "No Hispanics" but she could, when they showed up (or possibly during pre-screening) tell them no Hispanics. I feel this puts more work on Mrs. Murphy AND leads some potential applicants on, but hey, I didn't write the law.