The Landlord Protection Agency  
Main Menu, Landlord Protection Agency homepage Membership With The Landlord Protection Agency Free Landlord Services Member Services  

Re: This is HARASSMENT by HOA BOARD MEMBER-need ad - Landlord Forum thread 151247

Re: This is HARASSMENT by HOA BOARD MEMBER-need ad by NY LL on February 13, 2008 @06:30

                              
The tenants are responsible for the annual lease agreement regardless of the actions of the other homeowners. A landlord is not responsible for the actions of tenants or homeowners towards other tenants. The LL only has the responsibility to enforce the rules and regulations of the community. In this case, you are not the LL for the community, just the homeowner within the community.
Nevertheless, to address the issues… Enforce all of your contracted rights to rent and/or sell the property. The family of renters, understandably, would rather move than deal with the harassment during tenancy or forbid a permanent sale and ownership. The sale of the rental is probably not going to happen with this family. Regardless, the family is responsible to fulfill their annual lease obligations. The HOA and the neighbor/member of the HOA may have a false sense of entitlement to choose who lives in the community. Regardless, the HOA or its members do not have the authority to dictate who the owner rents to or sells to within the guidelines of the covenants. To enforce your homeowner’s rights and protect your tenant’s rights, file a formal complaint with the HOA and reference only the covenant guidelines in violation. It is a stretch to make discrimination the focus of the matter. Without hard proof discrimination is only a speculation. The actions of the HOA member are enough to bring forth a claim. It may be difficult (if not near impossible since you live cross-country), but it seems like you would do well by becoming a member of the HOA board yourself. It pays to know people in “high” places -- form a relationship with the HOA members unrelated to the issues at hand. The relationships will come in handy down the road.
[ Reply ] [ Return to forum ]

Re: This is HARASSMENT by HOA BOARD MEMBER-need ad by Caligirl-n-ATL on February 13, 2008 @14:31 [ Reply ]
Thank you, I appreciate your advice, I can see where it would be difficult to prove discrimination. I do know once I present documentation of all the harassment to the the board whether on my own or through an attorney, it will be clear he has violated the covenants. Harassment which would cause someone to move out is severe.
I understand that my renters are responsible for their lease with me and they understand that they are breaking it, I don't feel right holding them to their contract and charging them for the missed rent in light of the circumstances, any suggestions for a fair resolution as far as the lease breaking goes?
Re: This is HARASSMENT by HOA BOARD MEMBER-need ad by NY LL on February 13, 2008 @15:45 [ Reply ]
This is the reason you want to enlist the services of an attorney before you take action to 1) permit the early lease termination and before you 2) contact the HOA Board in order to request their input to enforce the covenants in order to remedy the matter. This is not a situation that you want to pursue by trial and error. After all, these are people with jobs and a family to raise, they should be managed professionally and knowledgeably.
If the LL agrees to early termination of the lease, then there is no further recourse. The tenants will move-out and the HOA member/neighbor will have been effective. The HOA will never agree that the move was due to their actions when your actions as LL permitted the tenants to break the lease. Once the lease is broken you will be at square one in finding a new tenant. Most likely, the HOA member/neighbor will perform in the same manner to make the next tenant uncomfortable as well. Request that the current tenants allow time (at least 30-60 days) to consult with an attorney. The current tenants will probably feel more comfortable about staying in the lease knowing that the situation is being reviewed by a professional attorney and the HOA Board.
The information you send to the HOA Board should be limited to the correspondence detailing the complaints and complaint references. Do not send actual copies of the complaints to make their job any easier. Allow them to perform their own due diligence and research the matter on their own for discovery. The letter should be delivered with a specific legal remedy in mind. Without a legal recourse regarding the complaints for the HOA to consider and act upon, there will be no incentive for them to take action against the HOA member/neighbor. Please consult with several attorneys that specialize in condominium/community real estate matters before taking initiatives and matters into your own hands.
    Re: This is HARASSMENT by HOA BOARD MEMBER-need ad by Caligirl-n-ATL on February 14, 2008 @00:39 [ Reply ]
    I see, you are right I will do just that.
    What will happen if even after I ask the tenants to stay, they end up moving? that is what I suspect will happen, I have done that and more this last week, they started talking about moving just one week after moving in and I encouraged them to stay because I was doing what I had to do to handle the problem with the HOA and if necessary through an attorney and to just work with me and give it some time. I don't want to agree to to break their lease. I want to pursue this legally. On the one hand, I feel bad as the LL that the tenant has had to endure such harassment in such a short time, but on the other hand I don't want to bite the entire bullet here either, they don't HAVE to move, I told them I would handle the situation it won't always be this bad all the time, I will take care of the situation with the HOA legally one way or another so they don't have to move right this minute so they are choosing to move so I shouldn't have to lose the deposit and the lost rent when they move out while I try to re-rent it, I just don't know what's the best thing to do I guess as it relates to me and the tenant totally separate from the HOA liability thing.
    I spoke with two attorneys today and both thought their was liability on the HOA because this guy keeps throwing his board position into everything he does and says to these tenants and his harassment is the direct cause of the tenants wanting to move out, so we will see. I have yet to decide which one to retain. Any suggestions of what to look for in an attorney in this matter?
      Re: This is HARASSMENT by HOA BOARD MEMBER-need ad by xxx on February 14, 2008 @09:41 [ Reply ]
      Sometimes as a property owner you have to be tough, and to protect your asset you'll have to do 2 things:

      1) Not let the tenants out of their lease. Tell them you'll do whatever you can to help the situation, but that they have to call the police and document the harassment. If you voluntarily let them out of their lease, it will be hard to go after the HOA, and this guy will keep doing this to future tenants.

      2) Put together a file on the harassment, send it to the HOA, basically taking the position that this guy is acting under the authority of the HOA and you are going to sue them if it does not stop. Put a scare into them, and protect your assets. Make sure you do this with an attorney.

      I know you feel bad for the tenants, but you're going to have to fight this out, unless you're rich enough to not care if the house sits empty indefinitely.

      Keep in mind, this guy may not just be a jerk, he may be mentally ill. Have your lawyer do a search to see if there are other civil or criminal cases the guy is involved in.

      Re: This is HARASSMENT by HOA BOARD MEMBER-need ad by Terry (ca) on February 14, 2008 @14:53 [ Reply ]
      You need to document everything in writing, send to the board and management and then ask to be heard at a board meeting. Folks don't realize that suing an HOA is literally suing yourself and all your neighbors..their defense comes out of your dues, etc.

      You need to work it out with the board/tenants. Keep in mind you are only hearing one side of the story as well. Sure it is automatic to want to defend your tenants..but..you aren't living there either. That is why the best approach is to document in writing your concerns, then ask to be heard in a board meeting, preferably a closed session one.


Check-Out
Log in

Look-up
Associations
Attorneys
Businesses
Rentals Available
Rentals Wanted
Realty Brokers
Landlord Articles
Tips & Advice
Tenant Histories

Other Areas
Q&A Forum
Free Forms
Essential Forms
Landlord Tenant Law
Join Now
Credit Reports
About Us
Site Help



Contact The LPA

© 2000-2023 The Landlord Protection Agency, Inc.

If you enjoy The LPA, Please
like us on Facebook The LPA on Facebook
Follow us on Twitter The LPA on Twitter
+1 us on Google