The Landlord Protection Agency  
Main Menu, Landlord Protection Agency homepage Membership With The Landlord Protection Agency Free Landlord Services Member Services  
Ask the Eviction Attorney | Landlord Tenant Law Q&A

Q&A with John Reno, Eviction Attorney

The Landlord Protection AgencyThe Landlord Protection Agency® is proud to introduce John Reno, Esq., a highly experienced Landlord - Tenant attorney based on Long Island, NY.

Mr. Reno has engaged in Landlord / Tenant practice in the District Courts of Nassau and Suffolk for the last 30 years. He prides himself on prompt legal action and direct client service.

"Over ninety percent of our practice in the Landlord Tenant courts consists of evictions of tenants, primarily for non-payment of rent. We also assist landlords in preparation and/or review of leases and consultation on other matters affecting the Landlord - Tenant relationship.

We find that Landlords who contact us have often waited too long to commence an eviction, usually in an understandable effort to resolve problems amicably. Landlords need attorneys who will not compound the problem with unnecessary delays or expenses. For this reason, our main priority is immediate action. In most cases, we commence an eviction within 3 days of being hired and have our client's cases in Court within 7 to 10 days of being hired."

If you are a landlord with a tenant problem you'd like to ask a question about, please feel free to e-mail me your question.
Please Note: Mr. Reno is an active practicing attorney with limited time and will do his best to respond to relevant questions. If using an I-phone or mobile device, please use full sentences and punctuation so we can understand you. The high volume of e-mails may require the LPA to enter your question into the LPA's Landlord Q&A Forum.

If you are a landlord with a tenant problem you'd like to ask a question about, please feel free to e-mail me your question.

Submit a landlord / tenant question for Mr. Reno
Please try to keep your questions as short and to the point as possible.

John Reno also does Mortgage Loan Modifications (Nationwide).
(Mention The LPA for a 10% discount!)

If you are a Landlord on Long Island, NY, and wish for Mr. Reno to handle your landlord - tenant case,
please provide your contact information: e-mail Mr. Reno (


Published 2014-10-21

Dear Mr. Reno:
my tenant had informed me of a short knocking out the electricity to the refrigerator. I let him put his food in my refrigerator and called two of my trusted electricians immediately. One was busy on a job but the other one told me he could come Friday and this was Monday. The tenant asked if he could have someone come out if he paid for it. I said yes as he did not want to wait.

He then $1500.00 worth of work done and expects me to pay for it. He gave the ok to the electricians he found on the internet.

It says in our month to month agreement that he has to get written permission to do any repairs.

Now he is threatening me with legal action and he did not pay the rent. What are my rights? He still had electricity in the guesthouse..just not in the refrigerator and microwave.
Thank you.

Marrsha, California

A: You really walked right into that one, Marsh. If he's got a paid bill (and proof he paid it) he can deduct it from rent because cooking facilities are given to habitability. You should have gotten it fixed pronto. Oh well, live and learn.

Oh, one more thing. You want to challenge the bill? Say it was unreasonable? Plan to bring a licensed electrician to court as an expert witness. You can't testify on your own.

Dear Mr. Reno:
Thank you for taking my question:

We signed a lease with a new tenant on June 2, 2014, they were to take possession on 8/1/2014. As a third party, can they go onto the property, change the locks and take possession? Locking out the current squatter even though they have filed Chapter 7? Keep in mind, the 2nd partner who filed is not on the premises only the 1st partner, her bankruptcy has been discharged. My attorney is filing for a relief from stay with 2nd partner (this will tie us up for yet another 60days). We are at wits end! We are senior citizens (66 & 67) this is our retirement, our only source of income.

Your advise is very much appreciated! Below is information on tenant/squatter in possession of my building. Building: Commercial Restaurant - Served 3 day notice and 30 day notice on June 13, 2014 both parties, Served 3 day and 30 day notice to McEwen and any and all occupants 9/2/2014 (2nd partner left premises on 6/22/2014)

4/1/2012 - Possession 3 year lease
1/2014 - Breached lease converted to month to month lease
6/12/2014 - 1 partner filed personal bankruptcy
8/13/2014 - Judge signed Relief of Stay Allowing us to evict tenant 8/27/2014- 14th day ended, date we could evict tenant
8/27/2014 2nd partner filed skeleton personal bankruptcy
9/15/2014 - bankruptcy dismissed
10/07/2014 Ė 2nd partner again filed bankruptcy

Breaches: no insurance, no workerís comp, havenít paid rent since May, living on the property, bringing in homeless vagrants in the evening to sleep in the property.

Mary Lopez, San Diego, CA

A: Sorry Mary. They are not squatters. They may be horrible tenants, but not squatters. A squatter enter the property illegally, like a trespasser. If your new tenants try a lock out, they're cruisin for a bruisin.

Dear Mr. Reno:
A tenant moved in 4 months ago She agreed to pay water bill. I just found out she didn't pay and the bill. They water company put a lock on the meter She keeps breaking the lock. Because every time the meter lock is broken it cost over 100 each time. The bill is over 1000. She never put it in her name. Now she is trying to Sue me.

Bridgette, Florida

A: Sounds like a 30 day notice is in order. Then YOU sue HER. But evict her first. You may or may not get a money judgment for the water-but get her out. She's BAD NEWS.


Published 2014-10-20

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have an ex tenant who agreed to lease my property (warehouse) to a lessee who signed a lease, on which they did not perform. I let them out of the lease 10 days after it started. They move in material which is still there. I had them sign a termination of lease agreement so that I could lease it out to another. How do I get rid of there stuff. I will send them a letter stating that they remove belongings, if they don't can I through away the belongings or do I have to store it.

Marc Dellorco, CA

A: They signed the termination of lease; they've given up possession, the property is abandoned and you can discard it. (you should promptly let them know, but basically you're cleared for take off.)

Dear Mr. Reno:
I am a landlord in Colorado and want to know what questions I am legally able to ask a prospective tenant's employer when verifying employment.
Thank you,

Kate Pettey

A: Date of Hire, position or Title, Salary (Anything else is a risk.)


Published 2014-10-17

Dear Mr. Reno:
My parents tenants lease expired 01/01/14 since then he was paying month by month until july. He didn't pay July and lived out his security deposit. In August he payed late and September he payed partial. Now I fear October he will not make payment. What process should I take to quickly expedite his eviction?

David, NY

A: You've got a dimemma, and it's an old one. You could go non-payment eviction, but they may pay and stay. Would that be okay?

Or, you could serve a 30 day notice and evict as a holdover, but that's slower and you'll lose 2 or 3 months rent. make your decision.

Dear Mr. Reno:
My tenant has given notice that she and family are moving from my home that I have rented to them for 4 years. Their lease was up at the end of September this year. They have been 10 days late 3 times this year but have made it up in fees. For this month, October, the wife paid half her rent and has promised to pay the rest, plus the late fees, on October 27. The problem I have at this time, is the tenants are now separated and the husband is living in a different state. She notified me today of her moving the end of November. I have their last month rent so November rent will be covered, and I have a good deposit from them. But, she does not want me to tell her husband what she is doing. Both he and she have signed the lease, and agreed when the lease ended last month, that they would pay month to month, as explained in #29 on their signed lease that I used from the Landlord Protection Agency.

Should I let the husband know what she is doing?
When she moves and the house is cleared of any damage, how do I split the deposit between them if the husband doesnít know that she is moving?
If I am obligated to tell the husband, what is the best way to let her know that I cannot keep her secret?

Mona M., State of Georgia

A: Do not mettle in "affairs of the tenant." This is none of your business. Don't get involved.

The security in cases like this is one check, payable to both if they're both on the lease. Let them split it up. That's a problem? It's their problem not yours. You're a landlord, not a marriage counselor.

Dear Mr. Reno:
I rented an apartment to a couple two years ago. I didn't have time to paint and do ordinary repairs as to they wanted to move in right away(in one week). I gave them a lease with a concession rider ($1,100 a month) in return they paint and do some repairs. They had a problem with the concession, saying they were scared I was going to raise the rent in those two years of the lease, and felt a couple of lines were unnecessary. Out of good faith, I unknowingly crossed out parts which basically say I can never raise their rent back to the original value ($1,800) for the duration of their tenancy. I am rent stabilized.

Since then they have taken me to court for harassment (twice) called the cops on my husband and I, called housing with any violation they can think of, and then refuse access. I am so far over $30,000 in debt. I just found out she is a licensed real estate salesperson. Is this legal on her part? What can I do? Sorry it is so long, but it is very complicated. Thanks for your time.

Lilly, New York .

A: Your "unknowingly crossed out parts"? What does that mean? You've got big trouble. See a Lawyer. (Right off hand- I'd say you're stuck right where you are-at $1100.)


Published 2014-10-15

Dear Mr. Reno:
With our landlord's permission, my boyfriend and I sublet a room in our apartment to a couple who did not sign an agreement with us and always paid cash. After an argument with the woman, the man left, locking us out of a smaller room used for storage. The woman told us not to let him back in because he had moved out, then stories leading us to believe he was unstable and had left bruises on her arms. After a few weeks she began inviting him back in without telling my boyfriend or I. When we found out we tried to talk to her about it, as we were uncomfortable with his presence in the apartment. She avoided us and became very hostile. On October 6 we told her to leave within 24 hours, she insisted on staying until the 11th which we told her we would allow, but completely vacated the apartment on October 8th. She kept the keys and is demanding money be returned to her for the rest of the month. We told her we would return the money, but would be subtracting costs for unpaid utilities and damaged blinds. She and the man have repeatedly threatened to call the police, accused us of not paying bills with the money they gave us (I have receipts proving we did) and said that they would sue us in small claims court if we did not give them the entire prorated amount for the time she would not be living with us. Can they do that? We cannot afford a lawyer or court fees, what can we do in this situation?

Amanda J., Michigan.

A: You have no obligation to prorate at all. Where did you find these Jerks? Thank God you got rid of them without an eviction. If they sue, go to court. You don't need a lawyer for this nonsense.


Published 2014-10-10

Dear Mr. Reno:
I just joined the LPA to get support for a problem I have with my tenants. After asking for a lease renewal earlier this year, my tenants were given another year (through June 2015). A death in the family has left our tenants with the opportunity to purchase a home through a family estate.

We offered to try to sell the house ahead of our planned schedule (spring 2015). We've arrange to have real estate agents, and contractors visit the property to prepare for sale.

Rather than accept that we're willing to break the lease if we sell the house, our tenant has stated that he is looking out for himself, and will not lose the opportunity to buy the other property. To that end, he's yet to pay his rent this month (it seems intentional as he's ignoring my calls).

It feels as though our tenant is trying to get evicted. What legal options do we have to compel the tenant to pay while still living in the house, when eviction is not a threat?

The house is in Fairfield, CT. Thank you.

John, CT

A: Hmmmm... You want to know how to complain about non-payment- other than by eviction?

You could sue them in small claims court for the rent. You'll get a judgment which will affect their credit- but that takes a number of months. (By the way, a non-payment eviction also gives you a money judgment- is much faster- and is what you should be doing.)

Dear Mr. Reno:
Hello, I received an email from my tenant that they slipped and fell down the outside front stairs during a rainstorm. He went to the ER, had stitches and Xrays, and 'had an expensive bill'. I wanted to know what my legal responsibilities are? Do I offer to pay his deductible or hospital bills (Im not sure if he has health insurance)? I do have an umbrella policy.
Thank you for your advice.

Holly R.

A: I hear all the time "If he falls on your property, you're responsible." That's a myth. You're only responsible if you're negligent.
Why did he fall? (Why so guilty a conscience?)

Dear Mr. Reno:
I had tenants, who just moved out, their lease was up. I went to check the house. In the house theres dog urine and poop on the carpet throughout the house. My neighbors told me they (tenants) had 3 dogs in the house and playing in the yard. They (tenants)never told me in the beginning of the lease. I checked the lease the realtor didn't put a penalty chrg for pets it's left blank. Can I still chrg pet fee from the security deposit.

Donna, TX

A: That dog wont hunt. Pet fees must be agreed upon. But if you replace the carpet or have it professionally cleaned, that expense can be deducted.


Published 2014-10-09

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have a rental unit in NYS. I leased to my tenant for the term of one year commencing on 3/1/14 and expiring on 2/28/15. They just handed me an early termination letter that they will be vacating by 11/15/14. There is no term penalty spelled out in the lease as it is a standard NY Residential Lease. Is there any standard penalty which applies? In future leases may I put a penalty which states that the tenant is responsible for the rent through the term of the lease or until it is rented if they terminate the lease early?
Thanks for your help.


A: It's exactly what you said. The penalty is the rent until you rerent. You hit the nail on the head.

Dear Mr. Reno:
My tenant with a 1 year lease expiring 03/01/15 has not paid one cent of the wastewater/stormwater/trash pick up bill since the first day of his lease resulting in a lien on my property which is up for sale. If he should need a repair, i.e., heat, air or leak, can I delay those repairs until he pays the bill? Thank you,

Patty V., IN

A: That's one approach but there's a pitfall. If the "repair" involves an essential service (like heat), the tenant can withhold rent until the repair is done. A/C, on the other hand, is nonessential, so you can let'em sweat 'til he pays the water.

Dear Mr. Reno:
Tenant wasn't paying rent so I took her to magistrate. The magistrate let her remain the home he called it "Stay and Pay". That was about the 20th of the month. She moved out the following month on the 4th. I got the judgment for all owed rent and late fees up until the 20th. It's been 2 months since she moved out. This tenant is paying on other judgments she owes at the magistrate. They wont tell me her new address. My question is what can I do now to get money owed to me? She works full time at a hospital, any chance to have the judgment come out of her pay? I didn't go and claim damages she left behind due to not having her current address.

Tammy from PA

A: You got the judgment "for owed rent." You've got the job. Start the garnishment. What are you waiting for?


Published 2014-10-06

Dear Mr. Reno:
My sister her husband & family moved in with me 3 years ago due to their 4 evictions.

They were suppose to stay 3 months & leave! They are Refusing to pay Rent! They refuse to leave!!!! They pay only a small portion of the utilities that they are costing me! They have destroyed my home & me financially! I have called the police & they do nothing!

How do I get rid of these horrible mean people legally! They know every trick in the book to be squatters!!!!

Please please help me , please!
Thank you,

Lisa FL

A: After I read the first sentence of your question- I shouldn't have read the rest. It was pretty much a done deal.

Thirty day notice to vacate. Get a lawyer. This can be tricky.

Dear Mr. Reno:
Hi, I'm Charlie from Honolulu, Hawaii.
I have a rental manager who takes care of my apartment. Our rental agreement is $1700/month plus utilities on a 1 year lease. The rental unit has an association, and the utilities can't be billed directly to the renter because it's bundled with the maintenance fee. So I pay the utilites for the month, and the renter reimburses me the following month through the rental manager. My understanding is that utilties is part of rent.

The rental manager brought in a tenant on Novemeber 1st, 2012, who is self employed. Problem was the tenant paid the $1700/month, but didn't pay the utilities. This happened for the first 5 months, all the while I was asking why wasn't the tenant paying electricity and why wasn't the tenant given notice to vacate. The rental manager said his lawyer advised we couldn't give notice to evict until there's a late payment. I was confused and angered. The tenant eventually defaulted on the monthly payment in May and thereafter only paid sporadically and partially. We started a Summary of Possession in June and were finally able to execute the writ on February 2014.

My questions are:

1) Isn't utilities considered part of rent if it's stated on the lease, and thus we could've started eviction earlier?
2) Can I sue the rental manager for the loss of rent, utilities, lawyer fees and the extensive damage the tenant caused, because of not responding quicker?

Charlie, Hawaii

A: 1. Yes, (but I have heard stories. Some judges wont evict for utilities, no matter how you word it & THAT'S WRONG.

2. No, you'll never be able to prove you would have gotten paid no matter what he did. It may seem obvious to you, but in court, its only speculation.

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have been renting a room since January 2014. She has never paid any rent. Can I just put her stuff out on the curb?
She is a heroin addict and I have a 8 year old son and a disabled 80 yr old mother. I'm afraid for them.

Dorothy, NY

A: Not in New York you can't. (not anywhere that I know of- she's there way too long for that.)


Published 2014-10-03

Dear Mr. Reno:
I rented to a woman and her three children and signed a four year lease. It's two years in, and apparently her partner/wife moved in three months ago with the partner's two additional children. I don't think the apartment is big enough for them. Can I evict them?

The tenant has always paid rent on time, but she's been complaining about repairs a lot lately. I can't stand her.

It's a pretty big apartment and she says it's big enough, but I say it isn't.

Oh btw, this is California and she lives in a rent controlled apartment.

Laurel D, CA

A: Why? Why? Why? Why would you give a tenant a FOUR YEAR LEASE? Why? You know these people will pack up and leave whenever the Hell they feel like it anyway. Now you're stuck with "Modern Family" 2 more years.

Dear Mr. Reno:
Hi my name is nadine...and my question is how do I evict my ex out of my apartment legally...I pay the rent...His name is on the lease...I have a month to month lease....your help in this matter is appreciated..


A: OMG! He's on the lease? So you're both tenants. One tenant can't evict the other. Sorry Nadine. My Solution: He stays- you go. Give the landlord your notice.

Dear Mr. Reno:
I had a couple claim they are on SSI & SSD. I am not familiar with those and asked for contact info so I could look into it before agreeing to show the flat. The caller had no phone number etc, so I could not help her. Can I legally refuse to rent to anyone who does not meet the minimum requirements I put in all my advertisement ? They are, No felony convictions, verifiable employment and a minimum credit score of 600, I do not accept sect.8, dss or any other agencies.

And how does one know if a service dog, truly is a service dog, since my research shows there is no legit registry for them ?
Thank You

Tim F., Landlord in Schenectady NY

A: Yes, you can refuse to rent to Section 8, as long as it's not unlawful discrimination (race, religion, etc.)


Published 2014-10-02

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have a tenant who has been through the eviction process 3 other times.I gave her notice . She ignored I have a hearing oct. 21 in phila.she broke my windows and called the police and said I did it.
1. What are my chances of getting the rent from the judgement?
2. Is there any way to push the hearing faster?
I moved out to get away from her because she goes into rages. After 3 times I would think the judge would lock her up. She is like a criminal. destoying property and taking advantage of tenant laws.

Annette, PA

A: 1. Slim 2. No

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have a tenant who signed a lease for 1 year. She stated she was single and would be living alone. (her 14 year old son is in boarding school). My tenant moved from Brooklyn to my residence and was referred by a friend. The tenant's boyfriend is a guest every night, the noise from the apartment (2nd floor) disturbs my quality of life, the tenant failed to cover 70% of the floor to reduce the noise level. The Tenant's lease is up Sept 2015. The animosity and anxiety are present in my living situation. I offered her the return of all her rental money if she vacated the apt. by Sept. 30. She agreed and then changed her mind. I need to have this tenant evicted for not living up to the terms of the lease, and to avoid any medical problems to me. Hoping you can give me some advice on whether or not I can have her evicted.

Rachael A

A: You have a major problem. Nothing in your question is going to justify breaking your lease. So you are stuck.

Your mistake was giving a lease, good through Sept. 2015, to share a house that YOU LIVE IN, with someone you didn't know. Next time, start with 6 mos. If it works out, extend it.

I hope for your sake, she defaults on the rent. Your only chance to evict is non-payment.
Otherwise, she pays... She Stays.

Dear Mr. Reno:
I'm trying to find out about what the rules/laws are when someone has a service dog. There is nothing on your website that addresses service dogs.

1. Can we charge a pet fee and/or pet deposit? If so, How much? We are in Wisconsin.

2. Can we ask for documentation that they indeed need a service dog and what documentation do we ask for?

3. I'm not sure what else I might be missing on this topic.

Sheila L., WI

A: Pet fees are common. Anywhere from $25-200 per month. I don't know of any regulations. Whether or not its a "service" dog shouldn't affect the fee, although they are better behaved. Usually, those dogs have a certificate.

Dear Mr. Reno:
My son & his girlfriend signed a lease but broke up 5 months into the arrangement. She has a stay away order of protection. He has removed 95% of his belongings. Can he have his name removed from the lease? He is concerned she will not pay the rent on time or trash the apartment. What are his options? Thanks so much!

J.B. in Long Beach, NY

A: Fat chance Jazzy. He's on the hook; I doubt they'll let him off- why should they? It's a contract. He can ask, but I'd be surprised.

If she defaults, they'll come after him. My recommendation: Prayer.


Published 2014-09-29

Dear Mr. Reno:
I'm in the process of doing a eviction in California, and was told by the eviction company that you can not get back rent from a person on disability? Is this true?

Carole, CA

A: No, not true (I think what they meant is that you can't garnish their checks or seize their checking accounts because disability money is EXEMPT from collections.)


Published 2014-09-27

Dear Mr. Reno:
I own a barber shop in Staten Island I rent booths to my barbers on week to week basis. I had an independent contractor lease agreement with a few barbers that expired months ago and now I want them out as they are now disrespecting me and my employees and basically disruptive to the overall business. As the "real" person on the lease of the entire space and they are basically sub leasing do I need to give then 30 days notice or could I tell them to leave immediately. I did write a termination notice giving them 24 hours to leave. I am now thinking that since we collect rent on a weekly basis that if I gave them 7 days I would definitely be good legally. Please advise thank you in advance.

John, NY

A: The first question is: will these "booths" be recognized by law enforcement as independent commercial rental units, like renting a store front in a mall, or is this just an area within your store that you control. To put it another way, if you call the police and say "this is my shop, I've asked this barber to leave and he refuses" will the cop make him leave. Or will he tell you to evict him. Probably, yes, because you've labeled it a rental.

If you have to evict, its still a 30 days. That's a minimum.

Maybe it was a mistake to call your payment "rent". That probably gives them all the rights of a commercial tenant. On the other hand, if you call them employees with a profit sharing plan, then you're responsible for their actions, so pick your poison.

Dear Mr. Reno:
I evicted a tenant that owes me two month rent plus close to $3,000 in repairs plus $1,450 in late penalties. How do I have to proceed now to have the ex-tenant pay me since he doesn't want to pay anything?

Marcos and I live in Florida.

A: You have exited eviction territory and are venturing into the world of collections. It's not my area, but for what it's worth, your only hope is probably wage garnishment. Got job info?


Published 2014-09-24

Dear Mr. Reno:
We have a tenant in our garage apartment who is always late on rent and bills. We want them gone as soon as possible. We do not have a rental agreement. They cause lots of drama and want them gone. The people in the front house have 7 kids and we don't have problems with them. The tenants in the garage apartment are trouble and we want them gone. Thank you

Maria, Texas

A: Give them a 30 day notice to vacate. If you serve it now, you ask them to leave on 11/30/14. (Is Texas 30 or 60? Please ask a local atty. I think it's 30.)

Dear Mr. Reno:
I sold my mobile home to my brother. He purchased the home but refused to pay the balance to transfer the title out of my name. Now park owner is going to evict me due to his non-payment of rent unless I evict my brother. Can I legally evict him and must I serve him 30 day Notice to Quit because there is no lease? He has had no utilities or water for 6 months due to his neglect and his non-payment of utilities. Can it be considered abandoned in the proceedings? Thank you for your thoughts.

Kelly from PA

A: So, I take it that you had an installment contract. He breached. If he's still there, you must evict Bro. Even if there's no utilities. If he's there, then he's there.


Published 2014-09-22

Dear Mr. Reno:
The tenant reported that there is a very loud noise when turn on the shower, and they request to have a licensed and professional plumber to take a look.

In TX, is it required by law that landlord needs to hire the licensed and professional plumber to fix any plumb relating problems Thanks,

Joy, TX

A: For repairs, no, for improvements maybe. Install a bathroom, you need a license. Fix a shower, no, or let me just say I'd be very surprised if your area has such a law.

Dear Mr. Reno:
Hello, If a tenant never moved in on a rent to own contract, do I still have to evict them? Tried to give him the keys but he won't respond to calls/texts and rent grace period for rent has passed.

Kimberly from Indiana

A: That's an extremely weird situation Kim. Not only don't you have to evict, I don't think you could even if you wanted to. He's not in possession and that's a requirement to give the eviction court jurisdiction.

So what you have is a breech of contract case, not an eviction.


Published 2014-09-19

Dear Mr. Reno:
3 years ago this month a tenant requested to be let out of lease early which I did with certain written stipulations regarding rent payment. The tenant had 3 choices of how to handle being let out of the lease early ( she only gave me a few weeks notice of this request) one of which required her to pay for the remainder of the lease if she did not pay the rent as agreed upon in writing for me releasing her (this was her choice of the options).

All of this was done in writing and she signed the decision she chose - which required to pay for the balance of her lease. The tenant did not follow thru with our agreement regarding payment or pay her final sewer & water bill balance which I had to pay. The tenant had moved out of state following this so I did not attempt to recover this via magistrate but now I have learned she is back in my area. Is it worth trying to recover any of what is due which is about 3500.00 now? Thank you for your time and consideration,

Allyson W., North of Pittsburgh PA

A: It's now a "small claims court" case. It only cost about $20 to start (You'll need her address though.)

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have a question that has put me in a bind. After my year lease expired I decided to stay for another month until my new apartment was finished paying month to month. On arrival to pay my first month to month payment I let my landlord know I was giving my monthís notice. He explained to me that there is a clause in the renters contract that states if you do not advise the landlord before the last month of your actual lease that their contract automatically rolls into another year lease without me signing anything and I am responsible for paying the rent until then even though I have no access to the apartment. Iíve paid double-rent 3 months now with no progress in finding a new tenant. I feel like they arenít going to even look for someone new because this is a much easier situation for them. I was met with the threat of the company taking me to collections if I decided I would no longer pay. Is this legal? If not, then what should I do in this situation?

Troy H., Kentucky

A: This is where I get in trouble because the answer varies from state to state. Yes, in general, the clause is legal and enforceable, EXCEPT in states that outlaw it. My state, New York has a special law. It automatically becomes month to month. No one year extension unless you sign.

So the question is, does Kentucky have that law. (Ask a local atty.)

Dear Mr. Reno:
We purchased a home in Badger MN and are unable to get the title to the property. The bank says we need to pay a lawyer $3,500.00 to get the title. We only paid $18k for the house and it is now only worth like $25K max. We don't have that kind of cash to pay for the title when we paid cash for the property. Can you help us figure out how we go about getting the title?

Hugs, Suse, MN

A: Didn't you get the title when you closed? What went wrong? Ya lost me, Suse.


Published 2014-09-18

Dear Mr. Reno:
I sent a letter with 30-day notice of a rent increase to 30-day Tenant at Will. Do I need an addendum to the original lease dated 15 months earlier?

Beverly, Massachusetts

A: It would be better if you had an addendum. Is the tenant agreeing to this? If so, they'll sign an addendum. If not, you may have to evict. Can't force'em to agree to an increase. It's "either, or." Either pay the increase or Sayonora.

Dear Mr. Reno:
We have 30 Apartments with option for 18 storage room thatís attached to property but not adjacent or inline with Apartment. I really need clarity on CO law on how to recover monies owed from an eviction. Can we place a Landlord Lien on the storage unit items until Apartment and Storage are paid in full? Our storage units have been optional and if needed a one line is added to their contract saying Tenant is in need of 1 10x10 storage unit @$40 per month.
Iím new and any help or reference material that can be thrown my way would oh so be appreciated.

Reecy, Colorado

A: That's a storage thing- different animal. I evict people and businesses. You need a storage unit guy. Sorry Reecy.

Dear Mr. Reno:
I rented my house to a couple, who refused to sign a contract. My wife and I are going through a divorce. The couple has not paid but claim that they paid my wife and have copies of hand written receipts from her. I filed a dispossessory and lost. How can I get them out? They are damaging my home.


A: Battle of the Roses?

Have you tried a 30 day notice? Because a non-pay is problematic when they're saying they paid her.

Also, you may have to get a "cease and desist order" through divorce court. I just saw one on a case I'm involved in. (Court told Hubby "stop taking rent!")


Published 2014-09-15

Dear Mr. Reno:
In June the apartment complex I live in changed owners; my lease expired in July. I received no notices from them and continued to pay my monthly rent. For the past two months I've been looking for a new place to live and found one I would like to move into by October 1st.
I paid my rent for September a few days ago as usual. Today I found a note on my door asking me to either renew my lease or pay a higher "month to month" rate as of October 1st. At the end of the note it said that i need to give 60 days notice before moving out.
So my question is, since my lease has been expired for months, do I still have to give 60 days notice (I.e., is this enforceable on their part) or can I still move out by October as I would like to.
I appreciate your time and attention.

Brandon C.

A: Contrary to popular belief, even though the lease expires, all the terms of the lease continue, except it's month to month. So if you had A/C included, you still have it.
Now on the 60 day thing, you may be able to fight that. It depends on the wording of the lease. Is there any indication that was intended to apply before expiration?


Published 2014-09-12

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have a tenant who hasn't paid in 4 months. My renter's license was up to date when she moved in, but the City of Philadelphia blocked my renter's license due to a trash collection fee. I experienced hard times when tenants failed to pay and fell behind with taxes. I was able to make a payment plan for taxes but not for trash. What can I do to get the tenant to leave so that I can be paid and then pay the City their money? Renter's license expired in February.

Mika W., PA

A: It's called an eviction- you've waited too long- but better late than never. Start your non-payment proceeding today! Either hire a lawyer, or get yourself down to the courthouse.

Dear Mr. Reno:
Is it ever wise to live in your own rental property ? We have 4 units and we want to move in one of them.

Toni G.

A: Why not? I see it done frequently. I wouldn't give any long leases though. You might dislike your neighbor. On the plus side, you'll be saving a lot of gas when you collect rent and answer clogged toilet calls!


Published 2014-09-11

Dear Mr. Reno:
We own some apartments in Las Cruces, NM. The tenants in one apartment did not pay their rent for the month of September and we notified by a neighbor that they were moving out without giving notice to us. Then they had their relatives move in without rent being paid or applying for occupancy. So now we have people trespassing in our apartment. What do we do?

Charlene, NM

A: I know you won't like this answer, but you have to evict the whole lot them like any other lying, conniving, dirtbags. No rent? Fine, you evict for nonpayment. When you evict them, you evict the kinfolk along with them. I know what you're thinking, that they're like trespassers, but the law doesn't see it like that. As long as the tenant is still legally in possession, they're his lawful guests, even though he hasn't paid the rent. Sometimes, the law just sucks and this is one of those times.


Published 2014-09-06

Dear Mr. Reno:
I am located in Colorado. I filled a demand for compliance notice on Aug 2nd. My tenant was waiting for financial assistance so we waited until that came in to receive pymt. On Aug 11th the tenant only give a partial Pymt so we filed the Compliant to proceed with eviction. Went to court on Aug 21st, where tenant's lawyer filed for trial. After court, we hired an attorney for trial. Went to trial on Aug 26th where the tenants lawyer made known that tenant filed for Chapter 13 Bankruptcy on May 30th in Indiana, of which we were not listed. Therefore the judge rescheduled us for court on Sept 5th and said he would not lift the stay. Our attorney talked to the bankruptcy trustee and they will not file a notice of intent to abandon.

Now our lawyer says all we can do is hire a bankruptcy lawyer in Indiana to file a motion to lift the stay. Meanwhile, her attorney is trying to throw the whole case out because I put our personal names on the compliant instead of our business name. Tenant will not pay for anything from this point forward, will not negotiate pymts and is violating the lease in other ways.

Our lawyer says this could drag on for months. One more thing, we rent the property from my mother-in-law who owns the property so this is a sublease. Is there anything we can do?

Casey, Colorado

A: You've already know the answer, you just don't like it, which I understand. You have to lift the stay. Only a bankruptcy lawyer can do it (I couldn't do it!)

As far as the names go, you should have used your names as shown on the lease. Did you?


Published 2014-09-04

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have a question regarding the security deposit. I have signed a one year lease with my Tenant in 2009. After the lease ended, we didnít sign a new lease, we just agreed she will stay under a month to month lease. My Tenant moved out after 30 days notice to vacate. I donít have a clause about the security deposit in the lease (a mistake), but my Tenant did sign a security deposit agreement that requires a 60 days notice to vacate. Can I hold the security deposit because no proper notice has been given? Or is a 30 days notice enough because we had a month to month agreement. Please, advise.
best regards

Nadia, Minnesota

A: You're on shaky ground there Nadia. The 60 day notice was during the one year lease. Now you're on a month to month. Probably thirty days would now be deemed sufficient.

Dear Mr. Reno:
Potential tenant supplied $500 deposit toward rental effective 9/1/14. I allowed her to work painting home @ $10/hr (I estimate that she spent 12 hrs, but asked her to document her hoursÖ.which she never did) - those monies would be applied to prorated August rent when home was ready for move in.

- Move in date - never discussed or agreed to, however she said she was staying at Hampton Inn, but I found she was living in my home using my utilities.
- In process of painting, she damaged carpet, woodwork and newly refinished bathtub as well as other damages amounting to approx. $300
- She never signed the lease contract, and when confronted regarding squatting, has asked for her $500 deposit back.

Can I deduct damages and daily rent from the $500? I have taken pictures to document damages.
Thank you,

Pam Wilson, OK

A: Go ahead. Deduct it. I think you have every right to. But you may end up in small claims court Is it worth the trip?

Dear Mr. Reno:
We have a no pet policy written in a lease. We have a student renting an apartment from us. She has a 12 month lease. Her lease is up in January 31,2015.
She is asking to have her dog, she had for five years while living at home.
She misses the dog. She claims to be in a lot of stress and her psychiratist recommends the dog as a service dog .
She has the paper-work for me to complete, allowing her to have the dog.
She also moved her boyfriend into the apartment and he is not on the lease.
Can we legally ask her to move before her lease expires?
Or will we have to let her have the dog?
Can we issue a non-renewal when her lease is up?

LF, Tennessee

A: This dog thing is out of control. You landlords are obsessed with your tenants dogs. Why can't someone have a dog?

Anyway, if you feel so strongly, just say "no, you may NOT have a dog. Or a boyfriend."

Then, she'll do it anyway. So then you'll drop her a line "Enjoy the dog in your apartment for the remainder of the lease, because it wont be renewed." So then you evict, lose rent for two months, have a vacant unit for another two or three months. There. Happy?

Dear Mr. Reno:
I live in NYC, my daughter moved out of my house at the end of April. After, asking her many times for my keys she finally said that she lost them. I changed my locks in June. She left behind some of her belongings. In Aug. she alleged that I illegally locked her out. The police came, she told them that she moved out in May. The police agreed with me and told her there was nothing that they could do. Now, my daughter and I are in landlord tenant court. My daughterís boyfriend also took me to court Can the judge award her any damages?

Sheila, NY

A: Could be trouble. (I hope you haven't rented out her room yet.) Damages will come up if they say you took her stuff. But I thought the rule was 30 days, She's out 30 days! On the other hand, she left stuff, so the court may find she never totally left. You better bring a lawyer or may have company for dinner.


Published 2014-09-02

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have a person in my home that was only staying a week. Been 3 wks. No lease. Refuses to leave. Sheriff said to file eviction. Now this person has mail coming to my residence w/no change of address. Is this legal for this person to receive mail to my home?

Kathy Hall, Florida

A: I thought the rule was 30 days, but your Sheriff has designated this a residence in 3 weeks, which is wrong, but there we are. That's where he lives.


Published 2014-08-28

Dear Mr. Reno:
I have a married tenant that is preparing to divorce and wants his wife out of the apartment. He is the only person listed on the lease. What action should he take to make her leave? Can I evict just her if she is causing a disturbance to the neighbors?

John in South Carolina

A: No. No. No. He can't evict his wife- and neither can you. For him, he needs a lawyer for a divorce- not an eviction. As for you, you need to keep out of it. It's none of your business and not your problem.

Dear Mr. Reno:
I own my apartment rent controlled (it's a co-op), I want to evict My grandchildren, I have already served them a "ten day notice to quit". My grandchildren have no way of moving out they say due to a part time job they claim is not enough to survive on they're own. I live in Manhattan, New York, they don't have a lease and I've never asked them to pay rent. I just want them to leave..... what should I do??? Thank you in advance

Loren, NY

A: Why 10 days? Where did you get that bad advice?

In New York State (which includes NYC) it's 30 days notice to vacate. There are some graps you can give only 10 days but I doubt you could fit them into those categories. Plus NYC is VERY, VERY strict.

You can ask him if the 10 days holds up. You try to do this yourself, be prepared to start over once or twice b/4 you get it right.

Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 Page 8 Page 9 Page 10 Page 11 Page 12 Page 13 Page 14 Page 15 Page 16 Page 17 Page 18 Page 19 Page 20 Page 21 Page 22 Page 23 Page 24 Page 25 Page 26 Page 27 Page 28 Page 29 Page 30 Page 31 Page 32 Page 33 Page 34 Page 35 Page 36 Page 37 Page 38 Page 39 Page 40 Page 41 Page 42 Page 43 Page 44 Page 45 Page 46 Page 47 Page 48 Page 49 Page 50 Page 51 Page 52 Page 53 Page 54 Page 55 Page 56 Page 57 Page 58 Page 59 Page 60 Next Last

Legal Disclaimer
The Landlord Protection Agency's "Ask the Attorney" column is for informational and entertainment purposes only. The questions answered by Mr. Reno on this site do not constitute an attorney - client relationship and are not to be considered legal advice. Not all questions will be answered and some may appear in the LPA Q&A Forum.
The Landlord Protection Agency recommends that you seek legal advice before using any of the material offered on this web site, and makes no guarantee on the effectiveness, compliance with local laws or success of any of the material offered on this web site. The Landlord Protection Agency is not engaged in rendering legal advice.

If you are a Landlord on Long Island, NY, and wish for Mr. Reno to handle your landlord - tenant case, please provide your contact information: e-mail Mr. Reno

Log in

Look-up Associations
Rentals Available
Rentals Wanted
Realty Brokers
Tips & Advice
Tenant Histories

Other Areas Q&A Forum
Landlord Tenant Law
Essential Forms
Free Forms
Credit Reports
About Us

Contact The LPA

© 2000-2014 The Landlord Protection Agency, Inc.

Home | About The LPA | Advertising Information | Affiliate Program | Contact Information | LPA Membership | Free Services | Landlord Q&A Forum | Landlord Tenant Law | Member Services | Free Landlord Forms | Essential Landlord Forms | Credit Reports | Report Tenants to Credit Bureau | The National Tenant Rating Bureau - The Deadbeat Database | Landlord Articles | Real Estate Investment Articles | Property Management Software | LPA Newsletter Archive | Landlord Tips | Take the LPA Landlord Test | Landlord Books | Associations | Attorney Directory | Rentals Available | View Rentals Wanted Ads | Real Estate Broker Directory | National Tenant Register | Business Directory | Landlord Links | Glossary | Site Map | E-mail a friend about TheLPA | Free Email LPA Newsletter | LPA FAQ | HELP using this site

If you enjoy The LPA, Please like us on Facebook The LPA on Facebook     or Follow us on Twitter The LPA on Twitter     or